Showing posts with label welfare. Show all posts
Showing posts with label welfare. Show all posts

Friday, October 26, 2012

Wall Street is the welfare queen

Via:  www.zerohedge.com  today’s must read, The Dark Age of Money, an impassioned recitative of how “capitalism” and “free markets” have been transformed into “monetary fascism”—worldwide.

All Bow to the Welfare Queen

Total governmental transfers and assumed liabilities related to U.S. financial institutions since 2008 exceed the entire history of all social welfare programs for all free world economies collectively since Bismarck (do the numbers, its true).

Friday, September 28, 2012

Am I my brother’s keeper? (reprise)

Via:  firedoglake.com

The Cainite Repubicans say no, they say the bottom 47 percent are all a bunch of victim whiners. 

But the bottom 20 percent is doing worse than I imagined, according to the BLS.  And many of us are only a job loss or two away from joining them.  There will be a need for low cost [ware-] housing for the Americans frozen out of the economy as more of them lose their houses and can’t afford market rents.  I’ve often said my retirement will probably be in a single-wide mobile home in the desert.

Expensive to Be Poor: Expenses Twice as Much as Income for Bottom 20% of US Households

By: David Dayen Thursday September 27, 2012 11:38 am

A new study from the Bureau of Labor Statistics out today probably won’t get as much notice as their other report showing the US gained 386,000 jobs more than expected. However, this one shows a persistent problem in America, that it’s actually expensive to be poor.

The average individual in the lowest 20% of the income ladder had take-home pay of $10,074 and average expenses of $22,011. That’s more than double, and it makes being poor nearly impossible to manage. The story for the second and third quintiles weren’t much better, with their expenses roughly commensurate to their income, meaning they live paycheck-to-paycheck and save next to nothing. But the expenses-versus-income report for the poorest Americans is almost unreal.

The Huffington Post puts some of these numbers in context:

This percentage of households includes many retirees, who are presumably living off savings.

Many of these households may be spending more than they earn through some combination of loans from family and friends, credit cards, savings, and payday loans. The government helps a bit with an income tax credit: The average bottom-fifth household’s after-tax income is $269 higher than its before-tax income. The income accounted for includes welfare and Social Security benefits.

Many are also taking on debt. In 2010, roughly one-quarter of the poorest fifth of households held a high debt burden, or had debt service payments exceeding 40 percent of their income, according to the Economic Policy Institute.

These households mainly are spending on necessities such as food, shelter, utilities, clothing and transportation. The average bottom-fifth household spent 87 percent of its after-tax income on housing alone last year.

Friday, August 17, 2012

Social justice creates the most social welfare

Barry Ritholtz is back from Europe, noting the relatively low stress levels among Europeans, who trust their social safety nets to get them through the European crisis (link).

After being exposed to Wilkinson’s research (here), I believe that the false god of Econ is not just completely wrong but actively evil in the ideas it promotes regarding social welfare.

The message of Wilkinson is that social justice creates the best social welfare outcomes, where social justice is prima facie defined as a much more egalitarian (but hardly “Rawlsian”) distribution of income and wealth than the US currently suffers.  And where the measures of social welfare are epidemiological, health-related measures, not phony economic aggregates like Gross Domestic Product.  Like, how well people are actually doing.

So in spite of the common view that Europe is doomed and America is still exceptional, I believe there’s a good chance Europe will do better in terms of human welfare in weathering the crisis than America will.

If America lurches to the right and the Republicans are able send America into a neo-feudal state, dividing the population into the ultra-rich and serfs (I say this with little exaggeration; see Barry’s comments on social classes in the link above), the weeping and gnashing of teeth will hardly produce beneficial economic results, except for those who have no national allegiance, namely the international money elite who are behind the Republican thrust.

Will the stress that a Romney victory would impose on America spark creativity or cruelty?  Romney’s vision has no place for social justice.  It is Social Darwinism in its rawest form.  There is a huge literature showing that stress actually has very adverse effects on the human mind and spirit (link).

Saturday, January 28, 2012

Bretton Woods super-nova reprise

My central thesis is the current debt super-cycle will end in a race to inflate and cause currency depreciation by all the world’s central banks that foolishly adopted the Western fractional reserve monetary system with the U.S. greenback as its reserve currency, that was at first pegged to gold up till Richard Nixon’s abandonment of the gold peg in 1971.

What a conservative, Nixon.  Wage and price controls, abandonment of any shred of monetary discipline for the entire world.. but he went to China…. What a dude!

Just as virtually every American must go up a learning curve with credit cards—many marriages have a “credit card moment” where the cards get cut up and a new fiscal regime begins—so the entire world has traveled down the borrow-and-spend-because-we’re-worth-it path that has led to the current mountain of debt on the shoulders of the global Sisyphus, as the world tries to push the boulder back up to the mountaintop.

The world is now on the steepest upward slope of the credit learning curve.

But central banks are not like people.  Central banks print money.  Too much money chasing too few goods equals inflation.  Inflation equals reduced purchasing power, and hence reduced real debt burdens.  This is all undisputed by all brands of economists.  The disagreement is whether the central banks, who have stated publicly that a little more inflation would definitely be a good thing, can get an inflation going in a liquidity trap, where, because everyone already has too much debt, they don’t want any more.

Ah, but even as all fractional reserve fiat money is technically credit debt, it is also a medium of exchange used for transactions for goods and services, including labor.

If an inflation is a sustained rise in the general price level, a working definition that should be acceptable here, then it is a labor market phenomenon as well as a monetary phenomenon.  I’ve gone so far as to say that “Inflation is always and everywhere a labor market phenomenon—a wage-price spiral—accommodated by monetary policy.”

So to get an inflation going in an admittedly quite deflationary environment (deflation is what happens when asset values supported only by bad debts on the liability side of the social balance sheet collapse as the badness of the liabilities is recognized, however slowly) you need to have some prices rise, perhaps because of a supply shock, and then to have businesses accommodate the however feeble demands for increased compensation to maintain real wages, a move that businesses would make only out of a renascent sense of social responsibility to labor and out of the record share of GDP they have garnered to capital in recent years. 

Then it is simply a matter of supply costs maybe going up a little more, maybe as the result of a different supply shock from a different sector—say the first was oil, as a war gets going in the Middle East, and the second is due to crop failures around the world because of a summer drought—and rather than send their economies into depression, the central bankers will accommodate as necessary, although with the level of excess reserves available in the banking system it may not take much accommodation in the initial phases of the new inflation.

And so a wage-price spiral is born that can support a sustained rise in the price level that can reduce the real value of outstanding debts.

The nation that gets the inflation going first wins in the super-nova of Bretton Woods.  Everybody’s got too much debt (in the Western world) and the first nation to depreciate its currency and the value of its debt picks up exports while paying down debt.  They reach the top of the mountain first.

And as I pointed out recently, the quickest way to get an inflation going—and I would maintain this applies even in a deflationary environment—is via the supply shortages and rationing that accompany a big hot war.

Hence I believe Daddy Warbucks and his military-industrial complex friends are pushing the United States toward war as quickly as possible.

But what will happen when the entire Western world rushes to follow, as I don’t believe the Europeans will be able to avoid the temptation in the event?

Collapse of the world financial system is a distinct possibility.  A galloping inflation or hyperinflation across the Western world would make international transactions highly uncertain.  Barter arrangements might be made for big ticket items like energy (already happening between Iran and China).

In the U.S. inflation and a return to positive real interest rates would at least kill the carry trades that have enriched the financial elite for a decade or more, would pull many homeowners into positive equity, and would most benefit those who locked in to super low rate financing as they leverage the funds into commodities.

When this will happen is anyone’s guess.  There are credible predictions by Charles Nenner, John Robb and others that a major war will begin this year or next.

China will implode into authoritarianism as their bifurcated economy tanks.  There will be no war with China this time, except for a possible skirmish or two in the Caucasus.  

The neocons, including Obama, who faces reelection, for which a war is always a useful ruse, will argue that we need to occupy the Middle East to assure supplies of “our” oil.  Israel will encourage the U.S. to decimate the populations of several Middle Eastern countries that it considers a threat to its survival.

All across America, Americans are transfixed by a Republican primary race that rivals the tackiest daytime soap opera for lurid content and lowbrow appeal.  Keep that TV on so you don’t have to think!

All the talk about taking America back will be put on hold for a moment as Chaos rears its ugly head and the last vestige of normality in the economy vanishes.

But then, as the world enters a period of Total Uncertainty, there will be an opportunity for revolutionary change.  For an amendment to the Constitution to declare that corporations are not people.  For progressive taxation that recognizes that the people sitting at the top of our corporations are not doing all the work, and that returns after-tax income distributions to levels found in healthy societies (cf. Wilkinson).

Because if we’ve learned anything in the years since Hank Paulson announced that if he didn’t get his way, a depression would start on Monday and martial law would need to be declared—if we’ve learned anything, it’s that the false god of Econ has lied to us lo these three or four decades.  Lied abjectly.  And the psychologists and epidemiologists, whose best work is ignored by behavioral economist whores running investment management businesses, have shown us that happiness and human welfare do not increase with GDP in any meaningful way, that more income above a level that satisfies some basic human wants and needs does not make us better off, but that what makes us happy and vibrant and alive and long-lived and healthy is living in an interconnected, more-equal-than-now human community, with a sense of interconnectedness and a lack of the chronic status insults, social stratification and isolation and personal degradation that accompany life in latter day banana republics like the United States.

The last world war produced the most pronounced leveling of the American income distribution in recorded history (cf. Income, inequality, debt, crisis and depressions).  There is a secret hope within the Beltway, methinks, that we can pull off the same trick again with the right conflict, started by the right false flag incident.

But the public is smarter than it has ever been.  IQ scores have been rising.  Information is instantly available around the world.  It’s hard to create a bogey man today.  The people know all the Hollywood tricks.  And they’re sick of war.

It’s no accident that folks in the U.S. military services overwhelmingly support Ron Paul.

So the next time the world enters a historical moment of Total Uncertainty, let’s be ready to use it to get what the 99 percent want, starting with a Constitutional amendment that corporations are not people, and from there on to a clean up of the laws that should govern this land, that the 1 percent who currently live above them may rejoin the human fold.

The readiness is all.

Peace.

Thursday, July 22, 2010

Cure poverty with money

The Benign Brodwicz program for the United Snakes of America is and always has been this:

  1. Give the unemployed a livable poverty level dole. 
  2. Provide universal public health care.  (The Bill Gates program for the bottom billion.)

Pay for the dole by raising marginal tax rates on our super-greedy, klepto-plutocracy, aka the American ruling class.

The following article from www.NewScientist.com provides support for my views.  America is as sick from this point of view as any banana republic.  But then, of course, we are one.

Die young, live fast: The evolution of an underclass

Editorial: Why biology should inform social policy

FROM feckless fathers and teenaged mothers to so-called feral kids, the media seems to take a voyeuristic pleasure in documenting the lives of the "underclass". Whether they are inclined to condemn or sympathise, commentators regularly ask how society got to be this way. There is seldom agreement, but one explanation you are unlikely to hear is that this kind of "delinquent" behaviour is a sensible response to the circumstances of a life constrained by poverty. Yet that is exactly what some evolutionary biologists are now proposing.

There is no reason to view the poor as stupid or in any way different from anyone else, says Daniel Nettle of the University of Newcastle in the UK. All of us are simply human beings, making the best of the hand life has dealt us. If we understand this, it won't just change the way we view the lives of the poorest in society, it will also show how misguided many current efforts to tackle society's problems are - and it will suggest better solutions.

Evolutionary theory predicts that if you are a mammal growing up in a harsh, unpredictable environment where you are susceptible to disease and might die young, then you should follow a "fast" reproductive strategy - grow up quickly, and have offspring early and close together so you can ensure leaving some viable progeny before you become ill or die. For a range of animal species there is evidence that this does happen. Now research suggests that humans are no exception.

Certainly the theory holds up in comparisons between people in rich and poor countries. Bobbi Low and her colleagues at the University of Michigan at Ann Arbor compared information from nations across the world to see if the age at which women have children changes according to their life expectancy (Cross-Cultural Research, vol 42, p 201). "We found that the human data fit the general mammalian pattern," says Low. "The shorter life expectancy was, the earlier women had their first child."

But can the same biological principles explain the difference in behaviour between rich and poor within a developed, post-industrialised country? Nettle, for one, believes it can. In a study of over 8000 families, he found that in the most deprived parts of England people can barely expect 50 years of healthy life, nearly two decades less than in affluent areas. And sure enough, women from poor neighbourhoods are likely to have their babies at an early age and in quick succession. They have smaller babies and they breastfeed less, both of which make it easier to get pregnant again sooner (Behavioral Ecology, DOI: 10.1093/beheco/arp202).

In the most deprived parts of England, people can barely expect 50 years of healthy life - two decades less than in affluent areas

"If you've only got two-thirds as much time in your life as someone in a different neighbourhood, then all of your decisions about when to start having babies, when to become a grandparent and so on have to be foreshortened by a third," says Nettle. "So it shouldn't really surprise us that women in the poorest areas are having their babies at around 20 compared to 30 in the richest ones. That's exactly what you would expect."

Consciously or subconsciously, women do seem to take their future prospects into account when deciding when to start having children. At a meeting last year, Sarah Johns at the University of Kent in Canterbury, UK, reported that in her study of young women from a range of socioeconomic backgrounds in Gloucestershire, UK, those who perceived their environment as risky or dangerous, and those that thought they might die at a relatively young age, were more likely to become mothers while they were in their teens. "If your dad died of a heart attack at 45, your 40-year-old mum has got chronic diabetes and you've had one boyfriend who has been stabbed, you know you've got to get on with it," she says.

It's the same story in the US. The latest figures, from 2005, reveal that teenage motherhood accounts for 34 per cent of first births among African Americans - who are more likely to live in deprived areas - and 19 per cent among whites. Arline Geronimus of the University of Michigan at Ann Arbor, who has studied health inequalities and reproductive patterns, points out that healthy life expectancy is short for African Americans and women depend on extended family networks for support. This means it is in their interests to have children while they still have relatives in good physical shape to help out.

The shockingly rapid deterioration in health experienced by women in poor black neighbourhoods also directly affects mothers. Even women in their 20s have an increased risk of conditions such as hypertension that would reduce the chance of a healthy pregnancy and birth. In research carried out in the late 1990s, Geronimus and her colleagues found that in Harlem, a poor neighbourhood in New York City, the infant mortality rate for babies born to mothers in their 20s was twice that of the babies of teenage mums (Political Science Quarterly, vol 112, p 405). Geronimus thinks the situation may be even worse now, given that the rate of health deterioration in black women has increased in the past decade.

It is not simply a case of teenage girls from deprived backgrounds accidentally becoming pregnant. Evidence from many sources suggests that teen pregnancy rates are similar in poor and affluent communities. However, motherhood is a choice, as both Geronimus and Johns are keen to point out. Teenage girls from affluent backgrounds are more likely to have abortions than their less-privileged peers. In terms of reproduction, the more affluent girls are best off concentrating on their own career and development so that they can invest more in the children they have at a later stage. "It seems that girls are assessing their life chances on a number of fronts and making conscious decisions about reproduction," says Johns.

Another important issue is whether or not a girl's father is around when she is growing up. Developmental psychologist Bruce Ellis, of the University of Arizona in Tucson, has studied extensively the effects of girls' relationships with their fathers. His research shows that the less involved a father is with his daughter from an early age, and the less warm the relationship, the earlier she starts having sex and, potentially, babies (New Scientist, 14 February 2007, p 38).

Fathers in deprived neighbourhoods are more likely to be absent, which could be because they are following "fast" strategies of their own. These include risky activities designed to increase their wealth, prestige and dominance, allowing them to compete more successfully with other men for sexual opportunities. These needn't necessarily be antisocial, but often they are. "I'm thinking about crime here, I'm thinking about gambling," says Nettle, and other risky or violent behaviours that we know are typical of men in rough environments. A fast strategy also means a father is less likely to stick with one woman for the long term, reducing his involvement with his children.

Paternal benefits

That is unfortunate, since a father's involvement not only delays his daughter's reproduction but also has a big impact generally on the life chances of his children. In a study of 17,000 people in the UK born in a single week in March 1958, Nettle found that where father involvement was greater, children had higher IQ scores at age 11 and increased upward social mobility through adulthood (Evolution and Human Behavior, vol 29, p 416).

Lower investment in children, whether it be through the absence of dad, less breastfeeding from mum, or less parental attention generally because there are more children in the family, comes at a high cost to the children themselves. For one thing, Nettle's large-scale study of families in England found that babies born in the poorest areas have slower cognitive development, which compromises their education and prospects later in life.

To all this you might ask the question, aren't poor people bringing their problems on themselves? If only they would wait a while before starting to have babies they might be able to invest more in each one, providing a better diet and healthier lifestyle. It is not so simple. "Children of low income, low education families don't do well regardless of what their parents' age is," says Johns. What's more, youngsters who delay parenthood may actually be worse off. "In a US study looking at pairs of low-income sisters, the ones that became mothers in their teens quite often did better [in terms of employment and earnings] because they had something to focus their energy into and create a better life for."

Nettle agrees: "Overwhelmingly the poverty into which a baby is born is going to be a big influence, whatever the age of the mother. It may be that there's not much pay-off for waiting and doing other, more middle-class behaviours that public health people want to encourage the poor to do."

People in deprived areas face two kinds of hazard, Nettle says. First, there are constraints on what they are able to do to mitigate their situation. Diet is a prime example: "It's much more expensive to get 2000 calories a day from fresh fruit and vegetables compared with eating junk food," Nettle says. Then the environment is often physically more dangerous and unhealthy. "People are doing more dangerous jobs. There is probably more air pollution, more car accidents, a higher crime rate, poorer housing - things you cannot really do much about, which trigger a downward spiral of faster living and less attention to health."

Once you are in a situation where the expected healthy lifetime is short whatever you do, then there is less incentive to look after yourself. Investing a lot in your health in a bad environment is like spending a fortune on maintaining a car in a place where most cars get stolen anyway, says Nettle. It makes more sense to live in the moment and put your energies into reproduction now.

Evolutionary theory can explain these behavioural responses to poverty, but it doesn't make them desirable. So what is the answer? What can be done to help people escape from the slippery slope of poor health, poor education and deprivation?

Governments are very good at being concerned about rates of teenage pregnancy and violence among young men, but Nettle argues that no amount of money poured into sex education and parenting classes will change the situation if young people don't see a decent future for themselves. To change behaviour we have to change the environment, which means that actually reducing poverty in the most deprived areas is likely to do a much better job than education schemes or handing out morning-after pills.

No amount of money poured into sex education and parenting classes will change the situation if young people don't see a decent future for themselves

Perhaps the most compelling evidence for this comes from real-life situations. In the mid-1990s, the residents of one poor, mainly Native American district in North Carolina each received a windfall in the form of royalties from a casino that had been built on their land. After the windfall, the researchers recorded a significant reduction in conduct disorder - the psychologist's term for antisocial behaviour - among the poorest children (The Journal of the American Medical Association, vol 290, p 2023).

On a larger scale, during the 1990s there was a dramatic decline in teenage birth rates in the US, especially among African Americans. In 1993, 6.4 per cent of black girls aged between 15 and 17 became first-time mothers but by 2000 this had dropped to 4.5 per cent (Social Science and Medicine, vol 63, p 1531). Geronimus puts this down in part to the strong economic expansion and increase in employment rates during this time, which offered young black women job opportunities they were unlikely to have had before. Teen births among African Americans are now rising again, predictably, given the recent economic nosedive.

It's all relative

Still, reducing poverty alone probably isn't the answer. In their book The Spirit Level (Allen Lane, 2009), epidemiologists Richard Wilkinson and Kate Pickett, of the universities of Nottingham and York, UK, respectively, emphasise the degree of income inequality in a society rather than poverty per se as being a major factor in issues such as death and disease rates, teenage motherhood and levels of violence. They show that nations such as the US and UK, which have the greatest inequality in income levels of all developed nations, also have the lowest life expectancy among those nations, the highest levels of teenage motherhood (see diagrams) and a range of social problems.

The effects are felt right across society, not just among poor people. "Inequality seems to change the quality of social relations in society," says Wilkinson, "and people become more influenced by status competition." Anxiety about status leads to high levels of stress, which in turn leads to health problems, he says. In unequal societies trust drops away, community life weakens and society becomes more punitive because of fear up and down the social hierarchy.

"Really dealing with economic inequalities is difficult because it involves unpopular things like raising tax," says Nettle. "So rather than fighting the fire, people have been trying to disperse the smoke." Politically it is much easier to pump money into education programmes even if the evidence suggests that these are, on the whole, pretty ineffective at reducing the effects of poverty.

There are two quite different ways that societies can be made more equal, Wilkinson says. Some countries, like Sweden, do it by redistribution, with high taxes and welfare benefits. In others, earnings are less unequal in the first place. Japan is one such country, and it has one of the highest average life expectancies and lowest levels of social problems among developed nations. Other important factors, says Wilkinson, are strong unions and economic democracy.

The bottom line, if young people are to avoid being channelled into a fast reproductive strategy with the disadvantages that this entails, is that they should have the chance to develop a longer view - through better availability of jobs and health support. They need reasons to believe they have a stake in the future.

Mairi Macleod is a journalist based in Edinburgh, UK

Wednesday, May 12, 2010

The collapse of effective demand (cont.)

First quarter 2010 data on the components of nominal aggregate demand show only consumption and government spending above pre-recession levels.  Investment spending is at early 2003 levels in dollars and would be lower in real terms. 

image

The uptrend in consumption is not supported by “real” personal income growth as pointed out by contraryinvestor.com in their May note—it’s mostly coming from government transfer payments.

 

Consumption out of disposable income is soaring again as consumers get tired of saving.

image

The picture of final sales to domestic purchasers shows domestic nominal demand at 2007 levels.

image

Employment/population has improved slightly, it is still at early 1980s levels, and the labor market continues to be very slack, with the unemployed experiencing extreme difficulties in finding a new job.

image

If the government experiences any trouble at all in floating its debt, the transfers to the lower income brackets will probably be diminished, causing a collapse of consumption spending.  The lifting of the “emergency” extensions of unemployment benefits would fall into this category.

The government could kill the economy more quickly in a number of ways, including requiring 1099s to be filed for all expenses over $600 paid by any business that would kill small business; by the imposition of a VAT that would kill small business; by a tax increase on any middle- or lower-income bracket.

The rich have conspired to suck a disproportionate amount of the income from corporate America to themselves, while keeping marginal tax rates on that income at historically low levels.  There is not organic personal income growth to support a recovery.  A “classic Keynesian” prescription would be for government to debt-finance a massive government investment injection to aggregate demand, but the bond market probably won’t like that.  Keynesianism as practiced by the mainstream has ignored debt/GDP, now at record levels. 

In the coming collapse of aggregate demand, the rich will have to answer the question, “Am I my brother’s keeper?”

Friday, January 22, 2010

US Crosses the Bernholz Line -- Hyperinflation Early Warning Signal

Via:  US Crosses the Bernholz Line -- Hyperinflation Early Warning Signal – EconomicPolicyJournal.com

The basic point:

Economic historian Peter Bernholz has identified that inflation starts to take on hyperinflationary characteristics some time after the deficits of a country as a share of government expenditure rise above a third and stay there for several years.


According to Bernholz, the great hyperinflations of France, Germany, Poland, Brazil, and Bolivia all occurred after deficits reached that magic percentage or higher (In Bolivia, it reached 91%). The United States crossed over the Bernholz line last year.

The time lags for onset of the disease vary following the indication.

A word about the definition of inflation:  Monetarists and Keynesians alike (neoclassical economists) generally follow Friedman in saying “inflation is always and everywhere a monetary phenomenon.”  Some Austrians say inflation is money supply growing faster than real product.

For practical purposes, let’s define inflation as a general and sustained rise in prices, all prices, including consumer and producer prices.  This is very different from a localized asset inflation such as America has recently experienced in stocks and real estate and commodities.  Let’s call these “asset inflations.”  Asset inflations are not so good at reducing real debt loads, as most people’s incomes (and wealth) don’t follow asset price bubbles upward—and they are definitely left behind when the bubble bursts.

For a general inflation to get going there must be a “wage-price spiral,” so that incomes rise to meet or at least follow the general rise in price level.  Hence, I define a general price inflation as “a labor market phenomenon accommodated by monetary policy.”  The money supply does indeed grow faster than real product in such a case.

I go through all this merely to point out the unlikelihood of a general inflation in the current environment, in which labor unions are nearly extinct, employment-at-will is the law of the land, fascistic Storm Troopers routinely terrorize citizens for trivial infractions, basic Constitutional rights to due process have been destroyed (the Government can “disappear” you legally if they designate you a “terrorist”—hold you forever without any due process, torture you, do whatever they like with you), and for the most part citizens respond by cowering in their homes, afraid they will be next to run afoul of the dystopian corporate police state, to drop into poverty and a life of internal exile or worse.

Now, the monetary authorities, in their wisdom, would actually like to see a general inflation, as this is their deus ex machina for dealing with excessive federal debt loads (debts of all varieties, really).  Hence, I expect the national governments, goaded by their monetary wizards, to try to “enfranchise” the working populations of the world somehow, in a desperate last stand of Bretton Woods (II).  If successful, they will accomplish nothing less than the the supernova of Bretton Woods II, a global hyperinflation. 

And hyperinflations generally end up permitting those with money and access to leverage, the Big Money, to expropriate the working folks of whatever they had left, and if historical precedent applies, to set the stage for full-bodied Fascism to arise.

The solution:  raise taxes on the rich in America who have twisted the income distribution so much in their favor, and provide workfare and health benefits to the people.  There is enough to go around.  We don’t need to run huge deficits, we don’t need to cut taxes on the rich, we don’t need more war.

Shame upon the ruling class of America!  You sit and watch as this happens without the slightest pangs of conscience?  As if you don’t know what is happening?  Shame upon you!

Shalom.

See also: 

U.S. Income Inequality Is Frightening--And Much Worse Than We Thought – businessInsider.com

Monday, September 14, 2009

Real consumption spending to rise from the dead, briefly

Tim Duy offers some dyspeptic comments on confidence and consumption similar to my own a few days ago.  However, he (and the rest of mainstream economics) continue to ignore research (however obscure) indicating the adaptation level theoretic foundations of confidence determination (reference).  Duy’s nice graph of year-over-year real consumption spending against the University of Michigan sentiment series inspired a similar effort with the “animal spirits” indicator that shows that real consumption spending is about to enter a growth phase.  The contemporaneous correlation of YOY real C and “animal spirits” is about 0.63; the regression with constant has an adjusted R^2 of about 0.33.  But the “animal spirits” indicator has proven extremely sensitive to turning points and trends, more so than the Michigan series.

This is consistent with my general view that the U.S. economy is entering a relatively brief “anti-deflationary” reflationary bubble that will resemble an ordinary business cycle except for the elephant in the room, namely, a growing national debt-to-GDP ratio coming on top of record levels of the ratio.  If I had to bet on whether private sector deleveraging will outrun public sector leveraging, I would bet not.  Not enough private debt is being written off.  The U.S. has more debt than it can service now (see Comstock’s piece).  In 1933 we were the world’s greatest creditor and could borrow easily.  Today our currency is at risk of substantial depreciation.  Our social contract is broken, with extreme inequality in incomes and wealth and a general self-defeating distrust of government by the disenfranchised.  Our deflationary collapse has only stalled.  The tragedy is that the rising “animal spirits” of the next several years will probably guarantee that no meaningful reform takes place—of the financial sector, of the government’s priorities and budget, perhaps even of health care.  In this environment both fiscal stimulus and quantitative easing are fool’s games.  The government should provide health care and livable workfare to the unemployed and limit any increase in spending.  America is a basket case but the government won’t admit it. 

Real consumption should grow 2.0-2.5 percent over the coming year, and may accelerate to about 5 percent YOY growth over the next four years, before the next downturn.  Here’s the chart:

image

Forecasted “animal spirits” in blue, real YOY consumption percentage in red.

Friday, August 28, 2009

It’s the debt *and* the politics, stupid

Paul Krugman has a good liberal heart but his attachment to macroeconomic figments has made him more than a little obtuse.  The bigger the deficit the better, says Paul, if it worked in World War II it will work this time.  But this flies in the face of history.  As Emmanual Saez has shown, WWII produced a miraculous equalization of the income distribution, which did not equalize much as a result of the New Deal.  Some hoped that 9/11 would be the “Pearl Harbor of the twenty-first century” to produce a similar result but it clearly didn’t.  The banking bailouts showed us how the government spends our money:  it distributes it according to the existing income distribution, with most going to the richest Americans.  And America now has a greater aggregate debt load than it did in 1929 (see this). 

As regular readers know, I propose giving a livable workfare and health coverage to the unemployed and involuntarily working part-time, now 25 million people, before spending a nickel on anything else.  They will spend the money wisely; research has shown that the bang for the buck is highest from direct income transfers like this (reference). 

The social contract is broken, Paul.  I’d like to hear your thoughts on how to remedy a broken social contract.  My proposal is hardly revolutionary, as it can be viewed as a way of keeping the people most likely to want wholesale change happy with their lot—but it addresses immediate human need and is better than validating the debt “death spiral” that you seem to be advocating, and that is much more likely to lead to revolutionary change—and war. 

Till Debt Does Its Part

By PAUL KRUGMAN

So new budget projections show a cumulative deficit of $9 trillion over the next decade. According to many commentators, that’s a terrifying number, requiring drastic action — in particular, of course, canceling efforts to boost the economy and calling off health care reform.

The truth is more complicated and less frightening. Right now deficits are actually helping the economy. In fact, deficits here and in other major economies saved the world from a much deeper slump. The longer-term outlook is worrying, but it’s not catastrophic.

The only real reason for concern is political. The United States can deal with its debts if politicians of both parties are, in the end, willing to show at least a bit of maturity. Need I say more?

Let’s start with the effects of this year’s deficit.

There are two main reasons for the surge in red ink. First, the recession has led both to a sharp drop in tax receipts and to increased spending on unemployment insurance and other safety-net programs. Second, there have been large outlays on financial rescues. These are counted as part of the deficit, although the government is acquiring assets in the process and will eventually get at least part of its money back.

What this tells us is that right now it’s good to run a deficit. Consider what would have happened if the U.S. government and its counterparts around the world had tried to balance their budgets as they did in the early 1930s. It’s a scary thought. If governments had raised taxes or slashed spending in the face of the slump, if they had refused to rescue distressed financial institutions, we could all too easily have seen a full replay of the Great Depression.

As I said, deficits saved the world.

In fact, we would be better off if governments were willing to run even larger deficits over the next year or two. The official White House forecast shows a nation stuck in purgatory for a prolonged period, with high unemployment persisting for years. If that’s at all correct — and I fear that it will be — we should be doing more, not less, to support the economy.

But what about all that debt we’re incurring? That’s a bad thing, but it’s important to have some perspective. Economists normally assess the sustainability of debt by looking at the ratio of debt to G.D.P. And while $9 trillion is a huge sum, we also have a huge economy, which means that things aren’t as scary as you might think.

Here’s one way to look at it: We’re looking at a rise in the debt/G.D.P. ratio of about 40 percentage points. The real interest on that additional debt (you want to subtract off inflation) will probably be around 1 percent of G.D.P., or 5 percent of federal revenue. That doesn’t sound like an overwhelming burden.

Now, this assumes that the U.S. government’s credit will remain good so that it’s able to borrow at relatively low interest rates. So far, that’s still true. Despite the prospect of big deficits, the government is able to borrow money long term at an interest rate of less than 3.5 percent, which is low by historical standards. People making bets with real money don’t seem to be worried about U.S. solvency.

The numbers tell you why. According to the White House projections, by 2019, net federal debt will be around 70 percent of G.D.P. That’s not good, but it’s within a range that has historically proved manageable for advanced countries, even those with relatively weak governments. In the early 1990s, Belgium — which is deeply divided along linguistic lines — had a net debt of 118 percent of G.D.P., while Italy — which is, well, Italy — had a net debt of 114 percent of G.D.P. Neither faced a financial crisis.

So is there anything to worry about? Yes, but the dangers are political, not economic.

As I’ve said, those 10-year projections aren’t as bad as you may have heard. Over the really long term, however, the U.S. government will have big problems unless it makes some major changes. In particular, it has to rein in the growth of Medicare and Medicaid spending.

That shouldn’t be hard in the context of overall health care reform. After all, America spends far more on health care than other advanced countries, without better results, so we should be able to make our system more cost-efficient.

But that won’t happen, of course, if even the most modest attempts to improve the system are successfully demagogued — by conservatives! — as efforts to “pull the plug on grandma.”

So don’t fret about this year’s deficit; we actually need to run up federal debt right now and need to keep doing it until the economy is on a solid path to recovery. And the extra debt should be manageable. If we face a potential problem, it’s not because the economy can’t handle the extra debt. Instead, it’s the politics, stupid.

Saturday, August 22, 2009

Quantitative easing and fiscal stimulus are both fool’s games

Via:  Daily Finance

It is still the pathetic wet dream of neo-Keynesians and neo-conservatives alike that inflation is going to accomplish the debt jubilee that they think is going to “reflate” our deflationary economies.

PIMCO: Fed needs to 'be irresponsible' if deflation appears
Joseph LazzaroJoseph

To borrow a phrases from the late, great Jimi Hendrix, wrap your mind around this one: would you root for an "irresponsible" Fed?

PIMCO's Managing Director Paul McCulley is doing exactly that. McCulley, in a PIMCO commentary, said that, if the U.S. economic recovery does not begin as expected in Q3/Q4, the Federal Reserve should push inflation above its long-term target to encourage U.S. consumers to spend money.

"The way to make monetary policy effective is for the central bank to promise to be irresponsible," McCulley wrote, citing a 1998 paper written by Nobel Prize-winning Princeton University economist and New York Times (NYT) columnist Paul Krugman.

My primary objection to this line of thinking is that it ignores the primary cause of deflationary depressions, too much debt on a highly unequal income distribution.  Simply put, some people have too much money while everyone else has very little money and too much debt—not enough money to spend to keep the circular flow of income and product going, let alone service their debt.  This is where we are today.  America is a rich country compared to most others and compared to ourselves a generation ago—there’s plenty to go around, but since Reagan the game has been tilted toward capital and rich folks.

But what qualifies Krugman’s remarks as obtuse, in the sense of biting off his own nose to spite his face (and I apologize for getting wonky a bit here, it’s something I’ve sworn off of since leaving academic economics, but every once in a while fall back into) is that the Fed can’t at once be credible in its stated policies of monetary control and at the same time promise to be irresponsible by igniting inflation.  That is incredible, literally.

It’s the debt, stupid, and the income distribution, the fact that the game is rigged by social conventions accepted by—or imposed upon—folks up to now.  Bad debts don’t get repaid by reflation, the cash flow coverage on the loans was never right and won’t be made right by inflation.  And not to get wonkish again, but you introduce all kinds of inefficiencies into the economy when you cause uncertainty about relative prices—because as Hayek pointed out, he who raises his price first wins—and given the state of our social contract, that’s not likely to be the people who need help the most.

What to do?  Follow William Black’s example in the S&L crisis and bust bad bankers, close their banks, write off their crap, break up Goldman Sachs (bring back Glass Steagall—there’s no way Goldman should be getting free money from the Fed), and provide a livable workfare-style dole and health benefits to the unemployed, who are going to be with us for a while. 

Quantitative easing and fiscal stimulus are both fool’s games, blind to the true nature of the problem, the broken distribution.  Fiscal stimulus will be distributed as unequally as the banking bailouts were.  The social contract needs to be renegotiated.

Reference: Income inequality, debt, crisis and depressions

Friday, August 7, 2009

Will rising “animal spirits” lead to ruin?

With the decline in the unemployment rate this morning, “animal spirits” improved.  We should see improvement in the Michigan Consumer Sentiment Index going forward, although it has slipped a bit recently.  There is noise in all economic series.

Click on chart for larger image in new window.

image

Even with unemployment climbing to about 11 percent over the next year, confidence will improve until the A metric (reference) actually becomes positive in time for the election, barring a currency crisis or other catastrophe in the meanwhile.  Confidence is one of the primary drivers of the business cycle.  However, given the double-whammy to consumption I noted yesterday from falling wages and salaries and increased saving, and the collapse of investment demand, growth is likely to be very, very slow.

This is bad news, in my view, as it affords the opportunity for the fiscal and monetary authorities to continue to pile up debt on the backs of American taxpayers.  Bernanke and Geithner will continue to bail out the bad debts of some big banks at taxpayer expense, and Congress will continue to rack up world-war-like deficits.

America can not service the debt load it has now.  Credit market debt is about 375 percent of GDP, higher than it was in 1929 according to reliable estimates.  Consumer and business debt is charging off at high rates likely to get worse.  As government crowds out private borrowing, private defaults can be expected to rise even more.  Since a lot of bad private debt of Wall Street firms is being converted into “good,” “risk-free” U.S. Treasury debt, this amounts to a continuation of the greatest expropriation of the ordinary Americans by the rich interests in American history.  Almost none of the high-rolling Wall Street speculators or their institutions have paid any price whatsoever for their trillions of dollars of bad bets.  (There was Lehman, but that was personal, Hank Paulson’s pet revenge project.)  At some point, demand for the dollar will collapse and rising import prices will drive the standard of living of the average American down even further.

We are watching an empire self-destruct in slow motion.  At the end of this process America will truly be a banana republic, with income and wealth inequality far worse than they are now, a hollowed-out state.  As McKinsey notes in a recent study, the human capital of the American labor force is subpar.  How will we climb back out?  The rich are free to invest their money anywhere in the world.

Only a radical reordering of American priorities in the next couple of years will prevent this.  There is no one who believes the Bush-Obama deficits projected over the next ten years are sustainable.  Ron Paul is the only elected politician who is addressing the scope of the change needed.  Everyone else appears to be playing politics as usual, acting as servants to the rich.  Even a five percent surtax on incomes over $1 million to provide health coverage to the poor has been fought tooth-and-nail by our greedy over-class.  The rich in this country have lost all sense of fiscal fairness in the worst crisis in three generations.  Ron Paul is the only politician of any standing who correctly diagnoses the problem, imperial over-reach inevitably leading to ruin.  As a physician, he has even moderated his libertarian positions to support government-sponsored health insurance for the poor, paid for by ending our futile wars.  I would add to that livable workfare for the unemployed to see them through the crisis, which is likely to last a decade or more.

Finally, is the unemployment report real?  Many would say not.  See TrimTabs’ research (here and here) and ShadowStats.  The Labor Department itself shows a decrease in the labor force of over four million in this decade.  Do you believe none of these folks want jobs?  All they have to do, reputedly, is to stop looking for a month and they’re out of the labor force.  The employment-to-population ratio is dropping sharply.  The government is aware of the psychological impact of the unemployment rate number so they manipulate it to keep it down.  The true unemployment rate is already in the teens.  A growing awareness of this reality may undercut the forecasted rise in confidence levels.

Click on chart for larger image in new window.

image

Monday, August 3, 2009

We are living through interesting times on a paleontological, evolutionary time scale

Lest there be any doubt we are living through interesting times on a paleontological, evolutionary time scale, read the first reference for evidence that we’re living through a major extinction event, and the second for evidence that humankind is hitting the wall with respect to growth of all kinds and is entering a phase transition to, one hopes, a sustainable state of affairs:

Someone asked me at Seeking Alpha over the weekend what my program was, that I was “confusing,” didn’t seem to fit an ideological mold.  That is correct. 

My program is basically this: 

(1) provide all unemployed Americans with a livable poverty level dole and provide all Americans with health insurance (not the same as “socialized medicine,” which means the government runs everything); and

(2) let the economy self-organize.

Instead of macroeconomic funny numbers, make human welfare outcomes the target of the “objective function.”  And do it mercilessly, no addition to debt.  If it requires income redistribution, so be it. 

Combine this with a ruthless writing-off (liquidation) of bad debts, letting the chips fall where they may, and recovery will come a lot faster than any other way.

Sunday, August 2, 2009

Prolonged Aid to Unemployed Is Running Out

Via:  NYT  The country needs a livable poverty level dole (and health care) for all the unemployed, not just those lucky enough to have qualified for unemployment insurance.  As I tried to show yesterday, our unemployment problem will persist because our collapse of demand is structural, i.e., distributional, at this point, just as it was in 1931.  The country will have 25 or 30 million under- or unemployed citizens for years to come.  Political philosophy goes by the wayside in a crisis like this; either we are our brother’s keeper or we’re hard-hearted.  The nation’s deepest values will be revealed in coming years.

Mainstream discourse still refuses to recognize that the system is collapsing (see this for example, arguing that 2-3% inflation will do the trick; or this, a CEO’s pipedream of an Objectivist world, from a big bank CEO who didn’t want or need a TARP bailout because his bank was actually well-run and solvent).  Useful:  Credit Crisis — The Essentials .

Prolonged Aid to Unemployed Is Running Out

By ERIK ECKHOLM

Over the coming months, as many as 1.5 million jobless Americans will exhaust their unemployment insurance benefits, ending what for some has been a last bulwark against foreclosures and destitution.

Because of emergency extensions already enacted by Congress, laid-off workers in nearly half the states can collect benefits for up to 79 weeks, the longest period since the unemployment insurance program was created in the 1930s. But unemployment in this recession has proved to be especially tenacious, and a wave of job-seekers is using up even this prolonged aid.

Tens of thousands of workers have already used up their benefits, and the numbers are expected to soar in the months to come, reaching half a million by the end of September and 1.5 million by the end of the year, according to new projections by the National Employment Law Project, a private research group.

Unemployment insurance is now a lifeline for nine million Americans, with payments averaging just over $300 per week, varying by state and work history. While many recipients find new jobs before exhausting their benefits, large numbers in the current recession have been unable to find work for a year or more.

Calls are rising for Congress to pass yet another extension this fall, possibly adding 13 more weeks of coverage in states with especially high unemployment. As of June, the national unemployment rate was 9.5 percent, reaching 15.2 percent in Michigan. Even if the recession begins to ease, economists say, jobs will remain scarce for some time to come.

“If more help is not on the way, by September a huge wave of workers will start running out of their critical extended benefits, and many will have nothing left to get by on even as work keeps getting harder to find,” said Maurice Emsellem, a policy director of the employment law project.

For many desperate job seekers, any extension will seem a blessing. Pamela C. Lampley of Dillon, S.C., said she sat outside the post office last month and cried because “it was the first Wednesday in quite some time that I’ve gone to the mailbox and left without an unemployment check.” The jobless rate in her state is 12.1 percent.

Ms. Lampley, 40, who is married with three children, lost her job as a human resources officer in January 2008 and had been receiving $351 a week, which covered the groceries and gas. Even so, she and her husband, who still has work as a machinist, were sinking into debt. Now, still poorer, she feels devastated because they cannot buy their son a laptop to take to college and she cannot give her 9-year-old son money for the movies.

In Ohio, where unemployment is 11.1 percent, Cathy Nixon, 39, a mother of four teenagers from Lorain, has been out of work for much of the time since June 2007, and her benefits — $313 a week — run out in September. Ms. Nixon is already fighting foreclosure and said she feared that when the benefits end, “we’ll be homeless.” She was unable to afford summer camp and baseball activities for her children, despite scrimping on basics.

Raymond Crouse of Columbus operated heavy construction machinery but has found no work since 2007. Mr. Crouse is 72 and receives Social Security but said that was not enough to live on. The $190 a month he has received in unemployment benefits enabled him and his wife to hang on to the house they bought 15 years ago, he said. But with the benefits ending next month, he fears that they will not keep up.

In ordinary times, employers pay into a state insurance fund, and workers who lose jobs draw benefits for up to 26 weeks. During recessions, Congress has often paid for extended coverage for an extra 13 or even 20 weeks.

In 2008, as the recession deepened, Congress provided 33 extra weeks of benefits. Earlier this year, President Obama’s stimulus plan offered an additional 20 weeks in states where unemployment surpassed 8 percent, if they adopted new federally recommended rules governing these extra weeks. (South Carolina did not make the changes, and benefits there are running out more quickly.)

Currently, people can draw benefits for up to 79 weeks in 24 states and from 46 weeks to 72 weeks in others.

The stimulus law also, through the end of the year, provided an extra $25 a week to all recipients, exempted a portion of benefits from federal income tax and subsidized Cobra health payments for the unemployed.

Representative Jim McDermott, Democrat of Washington and chairman of the House Subcommittee on Income Security and Family Support, said he would introduce a bill in September to provide yet another 13 weeks of coverage in states with unemployment rates of 9 percent or higher. “Legislators will line up quickly when they start getting calls from desperate constituents,” he said in a telephone interview.

The cost would be $40 billion to $70 billion, but the expense would be temporary, Mr. McDermott said.

Some business groups remain skeptical. Douglas Holmes, president of UWC, a group in Washington that represents businesses on unemployment issues, said that there were early glimmers of economic progress and that it was premature to extend benefits again. The money might be better spent, Mr. Holmes said, creating jobs and training people to move into emerging industries.

Traditionally, many economists have been leery of prolonged unemployment benefits because they can reduce the incentive to seek work. But that should not be a concern now because jobs remain so scarce, said Lawrence Katz, a labor economist at Harvard.

For every job that becomes available, about six people are looking, Dr. Katz said. “Unemployment insurance gives income to families who are really suffering and can’t find work even if they are hustling to look,” he said.

With the economy still listing, he added, a temporary extension can provide a quick fiscal stimulus. And, Dr. Katz said, when people exhaust unemployment and health insurance, many end up applying for disability benefits, which become a large, unending drain on the Treasury.

Ms. Lampley, whose benefits have ended, described the tough job market. She used to make nearly $15 an hour and has unsuccessfully sought office and clerical work at $8 an hour. Mr. Crouse said that even if new building projects were planned, construction slows in the winter cold.

And Ms. Nixon said that she had interviewed endlessly for jobs in real estate and office work and that even her teenagers could not find fast-food jobs because laid-off adults were filling them.

“I can’t find a job,” she said, “and you can’t survive if you don’t work.”

Sunday, June 21, 2009

Numbers on Welfare See Sharp Increase

Via:  WSJ h/t cryptogon  

By SARA MURRAY

Welfare rolls, which were slow to rise and actually fell in many states early in the recession, now are climbing across the country for the first time since President Bill Clinton signed legislation pledging "to end welfare as we know it" more than a decade ago.

Twenty-three of the 30 largest states, which account for more than 88% of the nation's total population, see welfare caseloads above year-ago levels, according to a survey conducted by The Wall Street Journal and the National Conference of State Legislatures. As more people run out of unemployment compensation, many are turning to welfare as a stopgap.

The biggest increases are in states with some of the worst jobless rates. Oregon's count was up 27% in May from a year earlier; South Carolina's climbed 23% and California's 10% between March 2009 and March 2008. A few big states that had seen declining welfare caseloads just a few months ago now are seeing increases: New York is up 1.2%, Illinois 3% and Wisconsin 3.9%. Welfare rolls in a few big states, Michigan and New Jersey among them, still are declining.

The recent rise in welfare families across the county is a sign that the welfare system is expanding at a time of added need, assuaging fears of some critics of Mr. Clinton's welfare overhaul who said the truly needy would be turned away.

[Welfare]

"To me it's good news," says Ron Haskins of the Brookings Institution, who helped draft the 1996 welfare-overhaul law as a Republican congressional staffer. "This is exactly what should happen."

Welfare cases peaked at above five million in 1995 and declined sharply after the 1996 law put time limits on benefits and emphasized moving recipients from welfare to work. The time limits vary by state, but the federally mandated maximum is five years with some exceptions; after that, benefits end.

The cash assistance program, called Temporary Assistance for Needy Families (TANF), was created by the 1996 law and replaced previous welfare and jobs- training programs. Funded partly by the federal government and partly by the states, it primarily assists women who have children and no job -- or a very low-paying one. The number of families on welfare had been falling steadily and, nine months into the recession, stood at 1.6 million in September 2008, the most recent date for which national tallies are available.

"This is the first real test," said Liz Schott, a welfare analyst at the Center on Budget and Policy Priorities, a liberal Washington think tank. "We always said how is it going to perform? How is TANF going to perform in an economic downturn?"

One clue, she says, can be found in a different measure. Although the TANF program seems to be accommodating increased need, it is doing so at a slower rate than another government initiative: the food stamp program. The number of food stamp recipients has risen in every state and was 19% higher in March than a year ago, a much bigger increase than the number of people on welfare.

[Welfare caseload]

Food-stamp eligibility is significantly easier than the criteria for receiving welfare, so food-stamp assistance tends to rise first. The food-stamp program covers a much larger pool of people who have trouble making ends meet but make more money than the allowable limits under TANF. In general, a family of four must have a monthly income of less than $2,297 to qualify for food stamps. Welfare, on the other hand, is designed as a last resort.

The average monthly welfare benefit in 2006, which reflects the most current data collected by the government, was $372.

Article continues here.